Lacey's Bridge Tavern

Nestled in the heart of Staten Island at 75 Innis Street, Lacey's Bridge Tavern is a standout destination for those craving classic American and Italian comfort food served with generous portions and a welcoming neighborhood vibe. This bar and restaurant effortlessly combines the warmth of a traditional tavern with the robust flavors of hearty, family-style dining, making it an ideal spot for both casual gatherings and celebratory meals.

The menu at Lacey's Bridge Tavern is a delightful journey through rich, satisfying dishes that reveal a deep respect for Italian-American culinary heritage with a creative flare. Popular offerings include their famous Meatloaf—a dish so hearty it feeds three with leftovers—alongside standout seafood specialties like the Lobster Shrimp Clams and Mussels Fra Diavolo over Linguini and the Broiled Lobster, which seafood lovers repeatedly praise for its fresh ocean flavors and expert preparation.

Dive into their Fried Calamari, served with sweet, medium, or spicy sauce options, or indulge in the smoky, savory notes of the Steak Pizzaiola—a 28-ounce boneless shell steak topped with melted mozzarella, sautéed onions, peppers, cherry peppers, mushrooms, and garlic, perfectly paired with creamy mashed potatoes. The menu also entices with family-style delicacies like Eggplant Rollatini, lovingly rolled with ricotta cheese and marinara, and the indulgently creamy Scallops Cajun Cream Sauce over Pasta. For those who enjoy a brunch outing, the Mimosas, Prosecco, and special Irish Coffee with Rumchata provide a festive refreshment lineup that complements the hearty fare beautifully.

The ambiance at Lacey’s Bridge Tavern warmly invites guests into a cozy, unpretentious atmosphere where the joy of sharing meals takes center stage. This is a place where laughter and conversation fill the air alongside the aromas of garlic bread, simmering sauces, and freshly baked breads. The décor strikes the right balance between rustic charm and casual comfort, ideal for families bringing big appetites or groups celebrating milestones.

One of the most praised aspects by patrons like Janet Manganiello is the sheer generosity of each portion—family-style servings designed to foster communal dining experiences. The value is undeniable, as hearty entrees such as the Chicken Gabriella with sautéed chicken, rigatoni, and vodka sauce come in large enough quantities to satisfy multiple guests. Frank Castellano highlights the consistently excellent meals and attentive service, especially during the much-loved Sunday brunch and the weekly Lobster Thursdays, which have become a local tradition.

Whether you’re craving the eclectic flavors of Clams on the Half Shell, the tangy yet comforting Kielbasa & Sauerkraut skillet, or the warmth of homemade Italian meatballs in marinara, Lacey's Bridge Tavern promises a rich and fulfilling dining experience. It’s no surprise that groups often choose this venue for celebrations, appreciating its lively yet intimate setting—just ask C Wu, whose celebrations here were marked by an unforgettable spread and sharing plenty of laughs and delicious bites.

While some guests, like *1JazzyLady4U*, note the drinks menu might not cater to the cocktail connoisseur, the strength of Lacey's Bridge Tavern lies in its culinary offerings and the genuine hospitality that envelops each visit. Joseph Iacono, a first-time visitor, was quickly won over by the freshness and abundance of food paired with excellent service, an opinion echoed by returning patrons.

For those who crave comfort food with an authentic edge, a lively yet relaxed atmosphere, and dishes served in hearty portions meant for sharing, Lacey’s Bridge Tavern is an essential Staten Island gem. Whether you come for a casual dinner, a family celebration, or one of their special events like brunch or Lobsterfest, you’re in for a delicious feast that feels like home.